Juxtaposition

Earlier this evening, I sent email in which I passed along a pointer to an AlterNet article about a 51-year-old black guy (at least, he'd always considered himself black) who took a DNA test that shows where your ancestry comes from. The test told him that he had no African ancestry at all. The article doesn't provide details about the test—about how it makes its determination, how accurate it is, what it means to be "57 percent Indo-European," etc. But the article is still an interesting study in culture and race in the US, especially the part about the guy's grandparents in Louisiana (who may've been part Native American, the article's a little unclear about that) having made a conscious decision not to label themselves as white.

At any rate, then I went and read a bit more of Le Guin's Four Ways to Forgiveness, which besides being an excellent book (I used to waffle when asked who my favorite author was; these days I can pretty firmly say it's her) is Le Guin's closest approach to dealing with issues of race and slavery (and, incidentally, the question of how the Ekumen handles membership applications from morally problematic societies).

And then I watched the movie that I'd previously picked out for tonight, without realizing that it was part of a theme: Spike Lee's Bamboozled.

I don't have any particularly coherent or summarizable thoughts on all this, and it's past time for me to go to sleep. But plenty of food for thought in each of those items, and the juxtaposition of all of them makes them even more interesting to me.

4 Responses to “Juxtaposition”

  1. Vera Nazarian

    How interesting, I was just thinking on a similar theme for a story where a person finds out they are of another race altogether.

    reply
  2. Larry Mackey

    I can’t offer anything as dramatic as the Black/White race confusion but latest genetic research reveals that the Irish people are not Celts. Their closest relations in Europe are the Basque people of Northern Spain. Both populations are Palaeolithic in origin and are not just pre-Celtic but also pre-Indo-European.

    The Basque people have retained their own language but the Irish appear to have abandoned theirs and their customs and surrendered to a relatively small group of Celtic invaders. I’d suggest you be careful where you mention this (Muldoon’s Irish Bar would not be a good choice).

    reply
  3. metasilk

    I seem to recall a movie along these lines: a black man and white man discover they are rather closely related. I rather want to say James Earl Jones and Robert de Niro, but I havent’ seen the movie, am only recalling the poster.

    It must be odd, casting some of one’s preconceptions, about who’s who and what it means, into some strange limbo.

    reply
  4. Vardibidian

    Jed,

    I thought I should point out an article in today’s NYT, which is completely worthless, but adds to the topicality of your topic. It also contains a major spoiler for a current movie, but I think if I mention what movie it spoils, that in itself constitutes a spoiler.

    Oh, and the movie mentioned about, with James Earl Jones and Robert Duvall, is called A Family Thing, and was an early Billy Bob Thornton movie. Just because I can’t help looking shit up.

    Redintegro Iraq,
    -Vardibidian.

    reply

Join the Conversation