Water purity

Did y'all know that somewhere around 25%-40% of bottled water in the US is purified tap water? And did you know that some bottled water (both here and elsewhere) is contaminated?

A Guardian article notes that Coca-Cola's brand of bottled water, Dasani, is purified tap water, and that the "purification" process Coke has been using in the UK ends up adding twice the legal limit of a carcinogen called bromate. Any increase in cancer risk due to Dasani is probably small, but the problem was sufficient to get the UK to take all Dasani off store shelves. I don't know whether there's bromate in the US version of Dasani as well; it's possible US legal limits are different, or it's possible that Coke uses a different process in the US.

The NRDC provides an extensive article about bottled water that notes:

While most of the tested waters were found to be of high quality, some brands were contaminated: about one-third of the waters tested contained levels of contamination—including synthetic organic chemicals, bacteria, and arsenic—in at least one sample that exceeded allowable limits under either state or bottled water industry standards or guidelines.

The gist of the article is that purity standards for bottled water are actually lower than for tap water in the US.

Meanwhile, in almost entirely unrelated news (but still on the theme of adding impurities to water), Danish artist Marco Evaristti has painted an iceberg red. Said Evaristti, "We all have a need to decorate Mother Nature because it belongs to all us. This is my iceberg; it belongs to me."

5 Responses to “Water purity”

  1. Jed

    Wacky—the first piece of spam I received after posting this had the one-line subject “carcinogen.” I assumed it was an unusually fast comment on this entry….

    reply
  2. naomi_traveller

    Ha. And I just finally bought a few flats of bottled water to serve as disaster emergency supplies…

    I still swear by charcoal-based filtration methods like the one Brita uses. For long storage, or a beverage option that isn’t carbonated or loaded with sugar, bottled water still wins out.

    reply
  3. Vera Nazarian

    We used to buy bottled water for years, but there has always been a sense there was something not quite right with it.

    But for the last year and a half, we swtiched to a two-step tap process. First, we got a Waterpic filter for the kitchen sink, and we collect that water and then double-filter it by pouring the Waterpic filtered water through a Brita filter. Works great!

    A single filtering alone is not enough, but the double filtering takes care of any residue, and the water is perfect now.

    I highly recommend this Waterpic/Brita combo for very yucky water places such as Los Angeles.

    And, it saves you tons over buying the bottled kind, plus it is definitely better quality fresh water. The filter replacements are much cheaper.

    reply
  4. Bondgirl

    During my recent cold, I watched all the old episodes of Penn and Teller’s Bullshit! (coming back next week on Showtime) and there’s an episode where they do a lengthy segment on bottled water. They do blind taste tests with tap and bottled water in NYC and, of course, the tap water wins. But even better, they had a waiter in a oohlala restaurant fill doctored up fake “bottles” of designer tap water with water from a hose and sell it to people for 5 to 20 bucks off a “water tasting menu.” I can’t believe these people signed the release forms for them to use the footage after dissecting the subtle differences in flavor between the different bottles of tap water.

    reply
  5. Celia

    Oddly enough, Dasani is the only bottled water I like the taste of. Our tap water here is the hardest stuff you can imagine (no, seriously–we get flakes of rust in it, and until we put a whole house water filter last year, we had no idea how clear tap water is supposed to be), so even double filtered, it’s still not much fun to drink (oh, plus we’ve apparently got low levels of pesticides in the water, which presumably get taken care of by filtering, since my mom’s fish don’t die like mine used to, but still, I got out of the habit of drinking tap water). All the other bottled waters end up tasting like nothing, which is not something I’m paying money to drink. 🙂

    reply

Join the Conversation