What if

I've been thinking vaguely over the past couple days about the notion of post-colonial speculative fiction, and about how few stories we see that are set on modern-day Earth in places other than predominantly white, Christian, and generally English-speaking nations. And it occurred to me to wonder what India would've turned into if the Europeans hadn't colonized it. And then it occurred to me to wonder what other subjugated nations and peoples would've been like. I've seen plenty of alternate histories in which the Aztecs or other South or Central American native peoples survive as world powers to the modern day, and I like those; but I think it might be cool to explore some other areas. Taking India as an example, it could range from "Europeans never got there" (is that part of Years of Rice and Salt?) to "local societies band together and fight off the Europeans" to "Europeans become trading partners rather than conquerors" to "locals develop advanced military technology earlier and invade Europe" to "East India Company fails [for whatever reason] and colony collapses economically". . . . All sorts of possibilities. (Though some of those may be wildly implausible; I don't know a lot about that period or place.)

But there's no way I'm gonna write such a story; too much research necessary, too little time available. I'm half-tempted to try to turn the idea into an anthology, alternate history stories about all sorts of conquered peoples (I recently heard an alternate-history speculation article about what would've happened if things had gone differently during an Old Testament battle between Jewish forces and a conquering king—Nebachudnezzar, maybe?), but I think I'll go read submissions until the urge passes.

(Hmm. Occurs to me that something like this might be a nice backdrop for a Spicy Zeppelin Tale. Must ponder further.)

Anyway, if this sparks ideas for anyone, by all means run with it.

5 Responses to “What if”

  1. Jay Lake

    Have you seen Eric Witchey’s alternate history stuff? He’s got something stunningly weird and interesting going on that’s out in circulation.

    reply
  2. Anonymous

    In Years, the conceit is that Europe is wiped out during the time of Tamerlane, so Europe certainly does not conquer India, and India becomes a world power.

    India needs some kind of solid technological base to beat up on Europe, but it’s not hard to imagine it giving Europe a run for its money.

    One problem would probably be climate — India being hot, and Europe being not, it would be awkward to invade. Maybe a proselytizing religion could work for a crusades-style invastion, or some sort of corporate structure to sponsor colonialist escapades. Or if the Indians developed mercantilism first…

    reply
  3. Fred

    Doh! Forgot to “sign” the above post.

    BTW, for more alternate history than you’ll ever want, check out the alternate history usenet group, alt.history.what-if, which was still pretty active last time I checked a couple years ago.

    reply
  4. metasilk

    You might enjoy reading Guns, Germs and Steel. This talks about *why* things turned out as they have, that is, what factors in human society & culture influence what kinds of development and expansion.

    reply
  5. betsy

    iron in michael swanwick’s periodic table of science fiction touches on a piece of alternate history along those lines. i just found the table today, and am pleased and amused.

    reply

Join the Conversation

Click here to cancel reply.